Percolator fans will defend their way of brewing like it's a family heirloom. But coffee snobs usually dismiss them as outdated machines that ruin decent beans. This debate gets more heated than most other coffee discussions, and there's a real reason for it. Percolators were the standard way to brew coffee in American households for a few generations before automatic drip machines came along and replaced them. When something gets that ingrained in your morning routine for that many decades (that signature bubbling sound, the smell that fills up your entire kitchen), it's going to create lots of passionate fans who have zero interest in a switch to something new.
Coffee experts have lots of technical complaints about percolators, and to be fair, they have some valid points. Most percolators heat the water well above the ideal range of 195 - 205 degrees F, and then they take that already-brewed coffee and push it back through the grounds a few more times. This pulls out bitter compounds from the beans and, at the same time, breaks down the delicate, layered flavors that you'd actually want to experience in a lighter roast or a higher-quality coffee.
A stovetop percolator will brew your coffee over a campfire, on a gas stove or anywhere that you can make heat happen - you don't need an electrical outlet at all. The stainless steel body is also going to outlast any plastic drip machine you could pick up at the store, sometimes by a couple of decades. Another upside is the caffeine content - you're going to get about 200mg in every 8-oz cup, and it's a fair bit more than the 95 - 165mg in a typical cup of drip coffee. A percolator is going to give you just what you want if you care more about strong, bold coffee and reliable performance than you do about nuanced flavors.
We can look at what makes percolator coffee different and see if it's worth a try!
How Water Cycles Through the Coffee Grounds
A percolator cycles water over your coffee grounds over and over again as it brews. Cold water starts off in the bottom chamber, and it heats up from either your stovetop or from an electric heater built into the unit ( depends on the type you have). Once the water gets hot enough, the pressure builds up and pushes it upward through a tube that runs right up through the center. Once the water makes its way to the top, it sprays out over a basket that's filled with your ground coffee. The basket has lots of small holes in it and lets the water soak through the grounds and drip back down into the main chamber at the bottom. From there, the whole cycle starts over again and just continues on.
The cycle repeats itself every few minutes as your coffee brews away in there. Most percolators will have a glass knob you can see through right on the top, and it lets you watch the whole process as it happens. The water bubbles up repeatedly and splashes against that glass in a steady, rhythmic pattern. The sound it makes is one of the best parts. A percolator has this gentle bubbling noise, and the sound actually changes as your coffee gets stronger. Some coffee drinkers don't even bother with a timer - they just listen, and they know when to pull the pot off the heat based on the sound alone.
Percolated coffee works differently from most other brew methods that you'll find, and what makes it different is how the water moves through the grounds. Instead of just passing through one time like it does in a regular drip machine, the water actually cycles through the coffee grounds over and over again. Every time that the water makes another trip through those grounds, it pulls out more of the flavor and oils from the beans - it's why percolated coffee tends to taste much bolder and have a fuller body to it (all that repeated contact with the grounds builds up the strength and intensity of the final cup).
Coffee Memories and the Camping Connection
Percolators bring back memories that other coffee makers just can't match. For a lot of us, the sound of coffee bubbling up through that little glass knob on top takes us right back to childhood mornings at our grandparents' house. That rhythmic gurgling became the soundtrack for plenty of family gatherings and lazy weekend breakfasts over the years. Anyone who grew up camping probably feels an even stronger connection to percolators. That old coffee pot sitting on a camp stove or balanced over a fire pit was usually the main event during those early mornings out in the woods. The fresh coffee, the pine scent, the campfire smoke - it all combined to create memories that stick with you for life.
Percolators used to be in just about every American kitchen - and I mean every kitchen. From the 1950s right on through to the 1970s, these machines were as standard as a toaster on your counter. The whole tradition of percolating coffee became a morning habit in a way that automatic drip machines have never quite been able to capture.
One of the biggest reasons that percolators have stayed so popular is how useful they are. A percolator doesn't need electricity, and it doesn't need any complicated setup to work. A gas stove, an electric burner, a camping stove or right on top of hot coals - a percolator will work on any of them. That flexibility is a big reason outdoor enthusiasts and anyone who wants a reliable backup option for when the power goes out still swear by them.
A percolator makes the whole coffee experience feel a lot more active and intentional compared to most other brewing methods out there. The process needs your attention as the coffee percolates. The glass knob on top of the pot lets you monitor everything as it happens, and when the color reaches that perfect shade, it's done. What makes it different is how it turns your morning coffee into something active to participate in, instead of just another background activity as you scroll through your phone or get ready.
Problems with Heat and Over-Extraction
Percolators have their fans, and plenty of coffee drinkers swear by them for good reasons. Still, they do have a few technical problems that are hard to work around. Temperature control ends up being the biggest issue with these machines. Most coffee experts will tell you that the water should be between 195 and 205 degrees F when it hits your grounds. Percolators usually run much hotter than that and get way closer to boiling.
When the water temperatures get too high, the more delicate flavor compounds in your coffee grounds will start to break down and deteriorate. What you'll wind up with in your cup is mostly just the bitter tannins, and these make your coffee taste harsh and pretty unpleasant. With coffee, hotter water works against you instead of giving you a better flavor.
Temperature is only part of what makes percolators so hard to work with. A percolator pumps the water up through a tube in the middle, and then it sends that water back down through the coffee grounds to start the whole process over again. The same batch of coffee gets brewed multiple times during a single cycle. Every time the water makes another pass through those grounds, it pulls out more of the compounds from them. Early on, the extraction is fine. But after enough of the cycles, it moves past that sweet point and lands squarely in over-extraction territory.
Over-extracted coffee tastes bitter and can take on this burnt quality that just covers up the flavors you actually want. The coffee that has already passed through the grounds once just gets pushed back through them over and over, and each time it cycles through, it pulls out more of the compounds that should stay right there in the grounds.
These temperature and over-extraction problems happen because of the way that coffee reacts when it's exposed to heat for extended periods of time. Even with those drawbacks, plenty of coffee drinkers still love their percolators and wouldn't give them up for anything. The brewing process actually does have a few genuine upsides, and they help explain why percolators have stayed popular for as long as they have.
Built for Years of Use
Construction quality is actually a big factor with percolators. Most of them are made from either stainless steel or enamel-coated metal, and that means there aren't many parts that can break down over time. No circuit boards to go bad, no heating elements to wear out after you make coffee every morning for years. Drop one on the kitchen floor, and it'll be just fine.
That durability matters in places where most other coffee makers would be useless. Set your percolator on a gas stove, a camp burner or just about any heat source you have available, and it'll work just fine. On cabin trips, on weekends in the woods or at any time you're away from reliable electricity, your coffee habit doesn't have to change one bit.
Volume is another big upside with percolators. Making 8 to 12 cups at one time is no trouble for a percolator (it's actually why they're so common at family gatherings and church basements). When serving many guests, percolators are better for that volume. With a pour-over setup, you would stand at the counter for ages and brew each cup one at a time.
The reliability and ease of use usually win out over the flavor and extraction downsides for many coffee drinkers who choose percolators. A percolator probably won't make the best cup of coffee you've ever had. What it will do is brew coffee every day, year after year, without causing you any problems.
How to Make Better Percolator Coffee
A percolator can still brew a great cup of coffee. But you do need a few small adjustments to how you use it. The biggest change is in your grind size - you want a coarse grind, about the same as what you'd use for a French press. The reason this matters is because a coarser grind prevents the coffee from turning bitter. When the grind is too fine, the water extracts too much during each cycle, and you wind up with the harsh, over-extracted flavors in your cup.
Timing matters a lot for how your coffee turns out with these brewers, and it's one factor that can make or break your cup. When you hear that perking sound start to slow down, you want to pull it off of the heat right away. Leaving it sitting there will make the coffee cycle through the grounds over and over, and that's how you get a cup that tastes burnt and bitter.
Most percolators are going to give you the best results if you brew for between 6 and 8 minutes. That time frame is where you want to be because it pulls enough of the flavor from your grounds without going too far and making everything taste bitter or burnt. You should also use cold water instead of hot water from your tap. Cold water gives you a lot more control over the brewing process, and everything can heat up at the right pace.
Watch those first few bubbles through the glass knob at the top. Once they start to bubble up in a steady rhythm, everything is working the way it should. From that point forward, you want to track your minutes and look at how the sound changes as the time goes on. Once the bubbling starts to slow down or loses some of its intensity, that's your signal to stop the process.
A few small adjustments like these will really help your cup.
Keep It All Natural
Percolators are a great choice for some coffee drinkers. But they're not right for everyone. If you like your coffee strong and prefer the traditional approach with a brewer that's going to last you for decades, a percolator could be just what you need. The tradeoff is that all that strength comes at a cost - you're going to lose out on some of the more delicate, nuanced flavors that modern brewing methods usually lock in better. The water passes through your grounds multiple times and can add a slightly bitter edge that not everyone is going to love - it's how a percolator works.
Coffee is a personal experience, and anyone who tells you they've found the one "correct" way to brew is probably just trying to sell you something. The best strategy is to test it against a few other popular methods when you want to know if a percolator is the right fit. Try a pour-over setup or maybe a French press and see how each one performs with your routine and preferences. Your goal should be to find a brewing style that actually makes you excited to wake up and pour yourself a cup each morning.
From our popular Skinny Iced Coffees (which are great for your metabolism by the way) to our Detox Kit that cleanses your entire body, we make natural products that work with your body instead of fighting against it. Our Constipation Relief Kit helps support your digestive system whenever you need it the most, and our full lineup of beauty and skincare items helps you look just as great as you feel. We make every product with natural ingredients because your health deserves the best. Check us out at Bella All Natural, and we'll help you live a healthier, more energized life.
