Beef tallow skincare blew up on TikTok, and now thousands of users want to know if they need to ditch their shea butter. Google searches for "beef tallow for skin" shot up by 326% year-over-year, and creators all over the platform started to post dramatic videos that said tallow healed their acne and changed their skin texture in just a matter of days. Shea butter has decades of research to back it up and a very loyal base of users who swear by it and refuse to switch to anything else.
These two ingredients get pitted against one another all the time - even though they actually have different uses. Tallow supporters love to talk about how chemically similar it is to human sebum, and shea butter fans will point you straight to the anti-inflammatory benefits found in clinical research.
The two camps have built up some pretty convincing arguments over the years. What you won't find in those viral videos is a straight answer about which one actually makes sense to use for your skin.
Let's compare these two popular moisturizers so you can find your perfect skin match!
How Beef Tallow Became the Skincare Sensation
TikTok videos about tallow suddenly pulled in millions of views, and users across social media were excited to share their before-and-after photos. Creators called it a "forgotten remedy" and said that it finally gave them the results they'd been trying to get for years. Content creators who share their experiences with tallow-based skincare report that it got rid of their acne.
Doctors haven't written tallow off completely. Viral fame and scientific proof are two very different things. When a product blows up on social media, it creates tons of excitement and gets everyone talking about it.
All that hype can definitely move inventory. But that doesn't mean there's strong clinical evidence behind the claims.
Personal testimonials do have value, and nobody's saying they don't matter when you're deciding what to buy. But they just can't replace controlled research if you want to get a great sense of how well something works. Tallow could be great for one person's skin and barely make any difference for the next person who tries it. Dermatologists want to see more official studies that actually track how tallow performs on different skin problems under standardized conditions that can be repeated and verified across different groups.
Pick the Right Option for Your Skin
Your skin type will matter far more compared to whatever trend happens to be popular on social media at any given time. Tallow performs well on dry or mature skin because it forms a protective barrier that locks the moisture right into your skin. When your face tends to feel tight or flaky as the day wears on, the way that tallow seals everything in helps quite a bit.
Shea butter tends to be gentler on your skin than most other options. It's also much less likely to irritate you if your skin is on the sensitive side already. Maybe your skin reacts fast and gets red at the slightest irritation, or maybe you've dealt with acne in the past, and you're trying to skip another round of breakouts - in either case, shea butter will be the safer choice to try first.
Tallow can be tough if you already have oily skin or if you get breakouts fairly regularly. Putting something as heavy as animal fat on your face might actually make it worse instead of better. The same properties that make it occlusive (which works well for sealing in moisture on dry skin) can also trap the oil and bacteria inside your pores where you don't want them. This doesn't mean that tallow is a bad ingredient across the board - it just means you should look at what your own skin type actually needs before adding it to your skincare.
To choose between the two, take a few minutes to check out your own skin and watch how it behaves throughout the day. When your face starts to feel dry or tight by lunchtime, or when you see your fine lines get more visible as your skin feels dehydrated, tallow could be just what you need. But when your T-zone starts to get shiny just a few hours after you wash your face, or when clogged pores are something that you run into regularly, shea butter will work much better.
All skin types are a little bit different from one another, so an ingredient that works well for a person with mature skin might actually cause problems if you have combination skin instead. Take some time to watch how your skin acts on a normal day, and you'll be able to tell which active ingredient is probably the best one for you to try first.
Quality Sources Make a Difference
Quality matters just as much as which ingredient you choose. Beef tallow from grass-fed cattle (animals that eat their natural diet instead of eating grain) contains far more nutrients than tallow from grain-fed cows. The same concept applies to shea butter - where it comes from and how it was made will change the benefits you get.
Unrefined shea butter contains the natural nutrients and beneficial compounds that work well for your skin. Refined shea butter goes through lots of processing to make it smoother and give it a longer shelf life for retail stores. But manufacturers wind up stripping away most of the vitamins, minerals and fatty acids during the refining process - and these are what make shea butter worth having. What ends up in the jar has a pleasant texture when applied, and it might look better sitting on the shelf. But it's lost most of the active compounds that would actually deliver skincare benefits.
A low-quality version of either product might not work at all, and in some cases, it can make your skin worse instead of better. If the tallow came from animals raised in poor conditions, or if the shea butter was over-processed and has lost most of its beneficial properties, you're paying for something that won't deliver. Your skin could have a bad reaction to mystery additives or fillers that they threw in there, or the product just won't do a whole lot.
Ingredient sourcing makes a massive difference in what you're actually putting on your skin. Grass-fed tallow contains a different fatty acid profile compared to conventional tallow from grain-fed cattle. Raw shea butter is loaded with vitamins and beneficial compounds. But most of them get destroyed when they go through heavy processing. Plenty of brands will slap "beef tallow" or "shea butter" on their label and call it a day, which doesn't tell you much about the quality or potency of what's in that jar.
When buying either one, look for brands that are transparent about where their ingredients come from. Grass-fed tallow and unrefined (or minimally processed) shea butter should be what you prioritize. The premium versions cost more money up front, and I won't pretend otherwise. The investment pays off, though - you're buying ingredients with true potency instead of watered-down alternatives that'll just sit in your cabinet.
Common Problems with Tallow on Skin
Smell is one of the first concerns that comes up when you're trying to choose between these two ingredients. Beef tallow goes through plenty of processing to remove the beefy scent that you'd expect from an animal-based product. Most of the high-quality tallow products wind up being nearly odorless after all that refinement, though some versions can still have a very slight animal smell right when you open the container. The upside is that any smell that's left tends to fade within a few seconds when you massage it into your skin. Shea butter has its own natural smell (lots of customers describe it as nutty or earthy). But it's usually a lot milder in comparison.
Greasiness is probably the other big concern for most customers when they're trying to choose between these two options. Tallow feels pretty heavy on your face when you first apply it because it's a really thick moisturizer. Eventually, it will absorb into your skin after a few minutes. The thick texture might take some time to get used to when you're accustomed to lighter lotions or gel-based moisturizers. Shea butter can leave your skin feeling greasy, too, especially if you put too much on in one application. The trick with these two is to get a small amount of it and give your skin the time to actually absorb it before you go and add more.
Clogged pores come up quite a bit as a concern for customers. It shouldn't clog your pores at all on paper. Beef tallow has a low comedogenic rating. Those ratings give you a helpful baseline to work from. But everyone's skin behaves a little bit differently in practice. Breakouts after adding tallow to your routine might not even come from the tallow itself. Another product in your skincare lineup could be the actual culprit.
A lot of customers care about where their skincare products come from and what's actually in them. Anyone who wants to stay away from animal-based products will have to pass on this one. Beef tallow is made from animal fat. Shea butter comes from plants, so it works fine if you follow a vegan skincare routine. Customers who do use tallow will sometimes look for the sources where the animals were raised more humanely. What you end up picking will depend on what matters the most to you and how it fits with the way you want to live.
Use Both Beef Tallow and Shea Butter
You don't have to use just one. Plenty of customers will layer beef tallow and shea butter together, or they'll buy products that already have the two ingredients mixed in. This gives you those nutrients from tallow that work with your skin and the moisture benefits from shea butter at the same time.
Layering them yourself isn't hard at all. Just put the tallow on first since it works best as your base layer, and then you can add the shea butter on top of that to seal everything in. Some customers actually like to alternate between the two products based on what their skin needs on any given day. Everyone's skin is different, so there's no single perfect way that works for every person.
If you're not interested in animal-based ingredients, that's understandable, and fortunately, you have a few plant-based alternatives that work just as well. Kokum butter absorbs quickly and restores moisture to dry skin without any of that thick, greasy residue. Murumuru butter is a bit thicker and creamier by comparison, which makes it great when your skin needs something more intense. Squalane is another great option because it mimics the natural oils that your skin already produces, so it tends to work very well.
You'll find quite a few more options to choose from. Different combinations can serve different purposes, so you should try a few of them out to see what your particular skin type responds to best. Plenty of customers discover that when they blend a couple of ingredients together, they get much better results than any single product could give them on its own.
Keep It All Natural
Beef tallow and shea butter have benefits, and neither one will be the automatic winner for every person who tries them. Skin behaves differently from one person to another, and something that works beautifully for another person might not have the same results at all. What matters is that you have the facts now, which puts you in a position to choose whichever option makes the most sense for your skin type, your lifestyle and whatever matters most to you. Give whichever product you pick a few weeks to work and watch how your skin responds over that time period. Any skincare habit needs to be something that you actually like to use, and it helps quite a bit if you can see the difference it's making on your skin.
What you put on and in your body is one of the biggest decisions you'll make for your health. Most of us already know what's right for us. But it's way harder to actually stick with it. Our entire product line was designed to remove that barrier and make it easy for you to stick with healthier habits. The Skinny Iced Coffees will speed up your metabolism, and the Detox Kit is meant to let your body reset itself and work the way that it should. We also carry a Constipation Relief Kit if you're struggling with digestion, along with natural beauty and skincare products that follow the same clean ingredient philosophy as everything else we make. Every product is built to give you real, obvious results without any of the questionable ingredients that you'll find in most alternatives.
Your health is different from everyone else's, and natural wellness products should actually deliver on what they promise. Bella All Natural has a range of detox kits, weight loss options and skincare products made with natural ingredients that can help you. Check out the products and find the right fit for whatever you're working toward with your body and your health.
